• LINCOLN IS PLACING PRIORITY ON SPECIAL ORDERS, CUSTOM ORDER YOUR LINCOLN TODAY
  • Start Your Order!
Jan 27, 2023
7 balls of pizza dough and a rolling pin sitting on a floured surface.

If you are searching for a quick, delicious, and simple dish you can find virtually anywhere, pizza is always a great option. Despite being a relatively small city, Plymouth, IN is home to numerous Italian restaurants and small pizzerias where you can take your friends or family for a dinner or grab a pizza for a movie night.


1. Bruno’s Pizza Plymouth

Located at 501 N Michigan Street, Bruno’s Pizza Plymouth is one of the best-known pizza joints in the city, serving the community since the 1970s. Owned and operated by an Italian family, this place brings the authentic flavors and fresh ingredients of the Italian region of Calabria to Plymouth. This restaurant offers takeaway and delivery and can be easily reached on foot from most other local landmarks in the city center.

Open Tuesday through Saturday, Bruno’s Pizza Plymouth serves both thin and thick-crust pizzas with a wide range of fresh ingredients including Italian mozzarella cheese, parmesan, fresh tomatoes, Italian sausage, anchovies, bacon, ham, mushrooms, garlic, green peppers, olives, and pepperoni. Throughout the years, new branches of this pizzeria have been opened in the nearby towns of Granger, Osceola, Riverpark, and Roseland.


2. Pizza Bill’s

A small restaurant located at 222 N Michigan Street in the heart of the Plymouth downtown area, Pizza Bill’s is a place where you can have a casual lunch or dinner with your family or grab a freshly baked pizza to take home for a gathering with friends. This local pizzeria is open Tuesday through Thursday between 11:00 am and 8:00 pm, Fridays between 11:00 am and 9:00 pm, and Saturdays between 4:00 pm and 9:00 pm.

Pizza Bill’s offers dine-in and takeaway pizzas made with a wide variety of ingredients and toppings customers can choose from. One of the most popular offerings is the “Bill’s Delight Pizza” with chicken, bacon, mushroom, and house ranch. This place also serves fresh salads and oven baked sandwiches.


3. Bourbon Street Pizza

After opening its first location in the nearby town of Bourbon, Bourbon Street Pizza has become a true local institution that nowadays features 10 locations in the region. The Plymouth branch is located at 582 N Oak Drive and can be reached in less than five minutes by car from the city center. Besides a wide variety of pizzas, this restaurant also offers pasta dishes, calzones, wings, appetizers, and Italian desserts.

Are you thinking of purchasing a new or used vehicle to travel around, explore the best local restaurants in the city, and take your family on memorable adventures? If the answer is yes, the search is over! Visit us today at Oliver Lincoln, explore our extensive inventory, and check out the flexible financing plans we have available for our customers.